Dear Colleagues:
For anyone practicing
neural therapy, the subject of mercury toxicity comes to the fore sooner or
later. Mercury toxicity is a common
cause of poor response to treatment; it may block regulation; it may underlie
"too many" interference fields, and it sometimes is a complication when neural
therapy is directed at interference fields with sequestered mercury, (e.g. the oral cavity and face). In this
situation, the patient is actually made sick by the neural therapy. Mercury toxicity is a large and important
topic discussed (in a limited way) in chapter 9 of my book on neural therapy: http://www.neuraltherapybook.com/
It is also a difficult subject. Unlike acute mercury toxicity, chronic mercury
toxicity is subtle and cannot be detected with the usual laboratory
methods. Most physicians suspecting this condition have come to rely on
chelating agents such as DMPS and DMSA to uncover the toxicity. A test dose
is administered orally or intravenously; the chelating agent circulates through
the body binding mercury and other divalent cations and is then excreted in the
urine. The amount excreted is said to
represent the "body burden" of that
particular toxin.
However, clinicians quickly observe that the correlation between the amount excreted
and the health of the patient is poor. Relatively healthy patients
sometimes excrete large amounts; tired and sick patients sometimes excrete
little, even though the history, examination and other lab parameters strongly
suggest mercury toxicity. The tendency then is to blame "impaired
detoxification".
A new commercial lab has just appeared on the scene that
shows promise in resolving some of these quandaries. Quicksilver Scientific http://www.quicksilverscientific.com/,
founded and operated by Christopher Shade, PhD offers two unique services:
1. Quantitative mercury analysis at extremely low serum
concentrations.
2. Mercury "speciation", i.e. quantitative analysis of both organic and inorganic
mercury in blood, hair and urine. (The commonest source of organic mercury is
dietary fish; the commonest source of inorganic mercury is dental amalgam).
Dr Shade demonstrates (using published literature almost 20
years old) that serum mercury levels are
actually a good measure of the body's burden in the chronic state,
i.e. the serum concentration is in equlibrium with that in the tissues. The problem for clinicians is that most labs
do not offer measurements at a low enough range for this knowledge to be
applied. Quicksilver lab does.
The second
breakthrough that Quicksilver Scientific seems to provide is an assessment
of the body's ability to excrete mercury through the liver and kidney
pathways. This is done by firstly
"speciating" the mercury i.e. measuring independently the methyl and inorganic
forms of mercury in the serum, and secondly measuring mercury concentrations in
hair and urine. Since the mercury in hair
is primarily in the methyl form and the mercury in urine is primarily
inorganic, calculations can be made to determine how well (or poorly) each
excretory pathway is functioning. It is
assumed that hair levels reflect excretion of methyl mercury through the
liver-bowel route.
This has some obvious therapeutic implications, and
especially for those practicing neural therapy. Not only do rational,
individually-tailored detoxification strategies need to be designed, but interference fields need to be identified
and treated, especially in the kidneys, liver, gut and associated autonomic
ganglia.
I have been starting to use the Quicksilver lab and have so
far found the results useful. Sometimes even knowing that a patient's excretory
pathways are working well is valuable knowledge!
However as valuable as this
information may be, I see one potential
pitfall in Quicksilver lab's basic assumptions. Serum mercury is said to "reflect the body
burden" because in the chronic condition blood mercury levels are in
equilibrium with those in the tissues.
This assumes equal availability of mercury for diffusion from all
tissues, but those experienced in neural therapy know this is not the case. Mercury is often sequestered in tissues
with reduced blood flow, typically those with chronic inflammation or interference
fields of various types including somatic dysfunction. This is evidenced by
neural therapy (or "deep" osteopathic manipulation of longstanding major
somatic dysfunction), mobilizing mercury that would otherwise not be reflected
in the steady state equilibrium of tissues with serum.
The question of mercury toxicity vs mercury sensitivity is
another remaining dilemma (and too large a subject to be discussed here) but
despite these limitations, I feel that
Quicksilver lab's new services are promising additions to the clinician's
armamentarium. I look forward to seeing how this plays out in not only my
own practice but also those of other clinicians.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Next introductory neural therapy course on November 12th
and 13th, 2010 in Ottawa,
Ontario, Canada.
http://www.neuraltherapybook.com/NTcourses.php.
Three-day introductory neural therapy course in Sydney,
Australia March 9-11, 2011. For more information contact George Stylian DO: 02
9524 4620, 0425 237 995 or gstylian01@optusnet.com.au;
FAX: 02 9525 9998